Sierra McCormick as Fay Crocker

Jake Horowitz as Everett

Bruce Davis as Billy (voice)

Gail Cronauer as Mabel Blanche

Cheyenne Barton as Bertsie

Mark Banik as Gerald

Gregory Peyton as Benny Wade

Adam Dietrich as Rodkey Oliver

Mallorie Rodak as Susan Oliver

Mollie Milligan as Marjorie Seward

Ingrid Fease as Gretchen Hankins

Brandon Stewart as Sam

Kirk Griffith as Lon Stemmons

Nika Sage McKenna as Daisy Oliver

Brett Brock as Fred Seward

Pam Dougherty as Mrs. McBroom / Jane Greer / Winifred

Lynn Blackburn as Ruth Reynolds

Richard Jackson as Speares

James Mayberry as Renny

Nicolette Doke as Josephine (voice)

Grant James as Arlo

Libby Villari as Grace (voice)

Gordon Fox as Pruitt

John Gindling as Cavage

Brianna Beasley as Ethel (voice)

L.A. Young as Benson

Chamblee Ferguson as Albert Cotesworth (uncredited)

PaulaSu Grisham as Basketball Fan / Mom (uncredited)

Rebeckah Boykin as Girl on Tape (uncredited)