Jack Dylan Grazer as Joey

Fionn Whitehead as Matt

Rainn Wilson as Mr. Hamby / Randy Michael Sadler

Mena Suvari as Carol

Graham Lutes as Tom Chowdee

Richard Fike as Officer Smith

Abigail Esmena Froehle as Officer Crane

McKenna Christine Poe as Teenage Girl on Car

Kate Duncan as Teenage Girl at Party

Seth Poe as Teenage Boy at Party

Shannon Cogan as News Anchor

Brian Tanke as Plunkett

Max Neace as Plunkett Jr.