Marc Maron as Mel

Jon Bass as Nathaniel

Michaela Watkins as Mary

Jillian Bell as Cynthia

Toby Huss as Hog Jaws

Dan Bakkedahl as Kingpin

Lynn Shelton as Deirdre

Timothy Paul as Zeke

Whitmer Thomas as Jake

Al Elliott as Jimmy

Tilcia Furman as Gabby

Benjamin Keepers as Ben

Robert Longstreet as Truther

Elise Mayfield as Phyllis

T'Darius Murphy as Mechanic

Michael Patrick O'Brien as Yach

Chris Steele as Boyfriend (uncredited)

Elisha Williams as Girlfriend (uncredited)

John Winscher as Civil War Conspirator (uncredited)