Dakota Johnson as Nicole Teague

Casey Affleck as Matthew Teague

Jason Segel as Dane Faucheux

Cherry Jones as Faith Pruett

Jake Owen as Aaron

Denée Benton as Charlotte

Gwendoline Christie as Teresa

Reed Diamond as Peter

Isabella Kai as Molly Teague

Violet McGraw as Evie Teague

Marielle Scott as Kat

Ahna O'Reilly as Gale

John McConnell as Glenn Hattaway

Jeronimo Spinx as Colleague #1

Jason Bayle as Rick Bragg

Sampley Barinaga as Kenny

Lane Alexander as Elf Valet

Paige King as Veterinarian

Jacinte Blankenship as Jeanette

Azita Ghanizada as Elizabeth

Chandler Head as Molly Teague (Age 7)

Veda Joy Martin as Evie Teague (Age 4)

T.C. Matherne as Male Friend

Mark Costello as Richard

Marguerite Pons as Elaine

Michael Papajohn as Dr. Felton

Mike Lutz as Dr. Abbott

Jennifer Pierce Mathus as Barbara

Gerald Brodin as Bill Faucheux

Susan Williams as Sherry Faucheux

Ritchie Montgomery as Uncle Ted

Richard Speight Jr. as Davey Faucheux

Lindsey Reimann as Girl #1

Evangeline Lindes as Teresa's Daughter (uncredited)

Hali Everette as Theater Crowd (uncredited)