Morgan Saylor as Mary Beth Connolly

Sophie Lowe as Priscilla Connolly

Margo Martindale as Enid Nora Devlin

June Squibb as Susie Gallagher

Annette O'Toole as Gail Maguire

Marceline Hugot as Doreen Burke

Gayle Rankin as Alexis

Will Brittain as Officer Justin Brennan

Skipp Sudduth as Officer Coletti

Ebon Moss-Bachrach as Gorski

David Coffin as Singing Fishman

David Pridemore as Singing Fishman

Adam Wolf Mayerson as Singing Fisherman

Mark S. Cartier as Singing Fisherman

Meredith Holzman as Dee

Linda Shary as Mary Margaret Connolly

Owen Burke as Paulie

Neil Odoms as Bob Gallagher

Kendrey Rodriguez as Beauty Shop Girl

Mary Coombs as Bartender

Kat Palardy as Tanya

Thomas Kee as Declan Crawley