Jessica Chastain as Tammy Faye Bakker

Andrew Garfield as Jim Bakker

Cherry Jones as Rachel Grover

Vincent D'Onofrio as Jerry Falwell

Mark Wystrach as Gary Paxton

Sam Jaeger as Roe Messner

Louis Cancelmi as Richard Fletcher

Gabriel Olds as Pat Robertson

Fredric Lehne as Fred Grover

Chandler Head as Little Tammy Faye

Jay Huguley as Jimmy Swaggart

Dan Johnson as Preacher

Michael MacCauley as Big Man

Grant Owens as Colonel Sanders

Coley Campany as DeDe Robertson

Craig Newkirk as Doctor

Wes Jetton as Male Nurse

Jess Weixler as Makeup Artist (voice)

Maurie Speed as Nurse

Lindsay Ayliffe as Old Teacher (Bible College)

Julie P. Tuggle as Pledge Lady

Kimberly Ann Parker as Reporter

Dana Marks as True Believer

Alan Boell as Stephen Chow

Randy Havens as Steve Pieters

Lila Jane Meadows as Tammy Sue

Carolyn Mints as Wanda

Kelly Borgnis as PTL Patron

Kelsi Chandler as PTL Patron

Joe Ando-Hirsh as Teenage Punk #1

John Johnson as Teenage Punk #2

Grayson Carter as Teenage Punk #3

Callie Lipian as Jamie Charles Bakker (Baby)

Caroline Lipian as Tammy Sue Bakker (Baby)

Robert Bailey as Nashville Singer

Deb Thomas Cox as Nashville Singer

Ellen Dockery as Nashville Singer

Jana King Evans as Nashville Singer

Lee Hilliard as Nashville Singer

Mark Ivey as Nashville Singer

Michael B. Lusk as Nashville Singer

Craig Morris as Nashville Singer

Savannah Morris as Nashville Singer

Donna Rhodes as Nashville Singer

Kira Small as Nashville Singer

Allen Andrews as PTL Sax Player (uncredited)

Chris TC Edge as PTL Crew Member (uncredited)

Kyle Riggs as Jamie Charles Bakker (uncredited)

Alan Dale as Self (archive Footage)

Hugh Downs as Self (archive Footage)

Jay Leno as Self (archive Footage)

Ronald Reagan as Self (archive Footage)

Christian Goins as Little Danny