Vanessa Hudgens as Brooke

Josh Whitehouse as Sir Cole Christopher Frederick Lyons of Norwich

Emmanuelle Chriqui as Madison

Harry Jarvis as Sir Geoffrey

Ella Kenion as Old Crone

Isabelle Franca as Claire

Mimi Gianopulos as Alyson

Jean-Michel Le Gal as David

Arnold Pinnock as Officer Stevens

Scott Ryan Yamamura as Evan

Jayne Eastwood as Eileen

Shanice Johnson as Paige

Scott Edgecombe as Santa Claus

Kristin Shepherd as Mrs Claus

Neil Babcock as James - Brooke's Ex

Olivia Gudaniec as Kaelynn - James' Girlfriend

Alex Armbruster as Young Husband at Tree Farm

Brittany Rae Robinson as Young Wife at Tree Farm

Andrea Senior as Christmas Caroler #2

Hayley Festeryga as Teenage Girl

Jacob Soley as Patrick (uncredited)

Rob Lowe as Derek

Kristin Davis as Kate (archive footage)

Chris Hobbs as Knight

Simon Webster as Reed

Kat Graham as Abby Sutton (archive footage)

Quincy Brown as Josh Barton (archive footage)