Billy Eichner as Bobby

Luke Macfarlane as Aaron

Guy Branum as Henry

Miss Lawrence as Wanda

Ts Madison as Angela

Dot-Marie Jones as Cherry

Jim Rash as Robert

Eve Lindley as Tamara

Monica Raymund as Tina

Guillermo Díaz as Edgar

Jai Rodriguez as Jason

Amanda Bearse as Anne

Debra Messing as Debra Messing

Peter Y. Kim as Peter

Justin Covington as Paul

Symone as Marty

Ryan Faucett as Josh

Becca Blackwell as Lucas

D'Lo as Tom

Harvey Fierstein as Louis

Bowen Yang as Lawrence Grape

Dahlia Rodriguez as Hannah

Derrick Delgado as Brian

George Dvorsky as Bruce

Jamyl Dobson as Joel

Brock Ciarlelli as Steve

Kenan Thompson as James Baldwin

Amy Schumer as Eleanor Roosevelt

Jillian Gottlieb as Samantha

Rick Crom as Grape's Neighbor

Everett Quinton as Melvin Funk

Thomas Vorsteg as Polyamorous Man

Julia Scotti as Straight Older Woman

Feliziano Flores as Rowdy Bear

Allison Reese as Aaron's Assistant

Gara Lonning as Receptionist

Nanie Méndez as Party Guest

Eileen Noonan as Party Guest

Courtney Chu as Teenage Girl

Ryan Daly as Grindr Guy

Brayden Morgan as Judgey Boy

William Popp as Pride Awards Football Player

Aidan Wharton as Football Player

Jovan E'Sean as Football Player

Joey Taranto as Singing Waiter

Courtney Bassett as Singing Waiter

Joshua L.K. Patterson as Singing Waiter

Kristin Chenoweth as Kristin Chenoweth

Edythe Jason as Paul's Grandma

Lorenzo Scott as Paul's Grandpa

Keith Milkie as Baseball Player

Alex Ringler as Baseball Player's Man

Cedric Leiba, Jr. as Harness Guy

Clayton Paterson as Hot Santa

Legendary Monster Babylon as Vogueing Man

Doug Trapp as Movie Exec

Jesús Martínez Jr. as Drag Queen

Daren J. Fleming as Drag Queen

Shannon O'Neill as Paula

Matthew Wilkas as Handsome Grindr Guy

Charles J. Roby as Wealthy Benefactor

Ben Stiller as Ben Stiller (uncredited)

Seth Meyers as Harvey Milk (uncredited)

Anthony DeVito as Straight Liberal Dad (uncredited)

Joanne Lamstein as Straight Liberal Mom (uncredited)