Banks Repeta as Paul Graff

Anne Hathaway as Esther Graff

Jeremy Strong as Irving Graff

Jaylin Webb as Johnny Davis

Anthony Hopkins as Aaron Rabinowitz

Ryan Sell as Ted Graff

Andrew Polk as Mr. Turkeltaub

Tovah Feldshuh as Mickey Graff

Marcia Haufrecht as Great Aunt Ruth

Teddy Coluca as Uncle Louis

Richard Bekins as Headmaster Fitzroy

Dane West as Topper Lowell

Landon James Forlenza as Chad Eastman

John Diehl as Fred Trump

Jessica Chastain as Maryanne Trump

Domenick Lombardozzi as Sgt. Tom D'Arienzo

Lizbeth MacKay as Miss Hellman

Jacob Mackinnon as Edgar Romanelli

Jeb Kreager as Cop

Marcia Jean Kurtz as Guide

Lauren Sharpe as Ms. Moustakas

John Dinello as Principal Sabell

Gerald Jones as Teenager on Train

Griffin Wallace Henkel as George Madison

Jen Weissenberg as Crazed Woman

Amy Warren as Woman One

Douglas Crosby as Cop One / Crazed Man

Eva Jette Putrello as Veronika Bronfman

Marjorie Johnson as Johnny's Grandmother

Lauren Yaffe as Teacher

Dupree Francois Porter as 1980s Student

Stephanie Groves as Student

Oona Girton-Marshall as Student

Ian Hernandez-Oropeza as Student

Aidan Christman as Student

Jude Washock as School Dance DJ

Skyler Wenger as Student

Psalm Mitchell as Student

Jack Parrish as Student

Stephanie Aguinaldo as Student

Diamond Washington as Student