Cooper Raiff as Alex Malmquist

Dylan Gelula as Maggie Hill

Amy Landecker as Mom

Logan Miller as Sam

Olivia Scott Welch as Jess

Abby Quinn as Georgia

Joy Sunday as Sophia

Ashley Padilla as DG

Tre Hall as Garrett

Alina Patra as Julia

Chinedu Unaka as Timothy

Nick Saso as Mason Birch

Wyatt Whipple as Seb

Juan Wood as Charlie

Andrew Hales as Jeff

Mallory Low as Caroline

Adan Rocha as Scott

Natalie Rousseau as Nellie

Teddy Padilla as Matt

Adam Foster Ballard as Jay

Tessa Hope Slovis as Not Maggie

Mike Raiff as Dad

Jay Duplass as Professor Notkin (uncredited)

Ayo Edebiri as Emily (uncredited)

Harrison Callaghan as Jeremy (uncredited)

Grant Harling as Professor Bittenbender (uncredited)

Macey Isaacs as Grace (uncredited)

Chris Kleckner as Guy with Knife (uncredited)

Bianca Pompa as Girl #1 (uncredited)

Jenny Leiferman as Girl #2 (uncredited)

Denny McAuliffe as Josh (uncredited)

Colin McCalla as Tyler (uncredited)

Leonora Pitts as Monica (uncredited)

Scott Pitts as Chandler's Father (uncredited)

Kainan Short as PJ (uncredited)

Melissa Stenger as Stage Actress (uncredited)

Eva Victor as Michelle (uncredited)

Will Youmans as Chandler (uncredited)