Houston Baker as Victor (archive footage)

James Carolus as Hunter (archive footage)

Elizabeth V. Costanzo as Brianna (archive footage)

Steve Diasparra as Randy Bucks (archive footage)

Elissa Dowling as (archive footage)

Melissa Heflin as Anne (archive footage)

Titus Himmelberger as Bishop (archive footage)

Mariah Joyce as (archive footage)

Kelsey Kaufmann as Christi (archive footage)

Jeff Kirkendall as Fletcher (archive footage)

Tina Krause as Nancy (archive footage)

Jamie Morgan as Lizzie (archive footage)

Joshua Pollitt as Harvey (archive footage)

Mark Polonia as Station Manager (archive footage)

Kyle Rappaport as Terry (archive footage)

Jennie Russo as Paula (archive footage)

Sarah Ryan as Sasha (archive footage)

George Stover as Mr. Carson (archive footage)

Ken Van Sant as Tommy (archive footage)

Greta Volkova as Ginny (archive footage)

Wyatt Wood as Drake (archival footage)

Ashley Wray as Marcy (archive footage)

Kathryn Sue Young as Katie (archive footage)

Vivien Latham as Freddy's mother (archive footage - The Axegrinder)

Randal Malone as Murdered Father (archive footage - The Axegrinder)

Darby Daniels as Jogger (archive footage - The Axegrinder)

Robert O'Connor as The Axegrinder (archival footage - The Axegrinder)