Guy Pearce as Father Peter

Vadhir Derbez as Father Daniel

Stephen Lang as Archbishop

Brady Jenness as Charlie Giroux

Robin Bartlett as Helen

Keith David as Father Louis

Chris Galust as Young Peter

Acoryé White as George

James Healy Jr. as Forensic Psychologist

Heath Freeman as Mr. Miller

Hannah Alline as Mrs. Miller

Tristan Riggs as Nicholas Miller

Stephanie Rhodes as Charlie's Mother

Major Dodge as Charlie's Father

Evangeline Griffin as Nellie

Johari Turner as Aaron

Björgvin Arnarson as Carson

Grace E Gonzalez as Jazzy

Seth Gutierrez as Sherman

Gail Cronauer as Archbishop's Secretary

Mykle McCoslin as Administrator

Gary Lee Reed as Priest

Garrett Schweighauser as Father Dunleavy

Silas De La Rosa as Young Daniel

Ethan Pogue as Young Daniel's Friend #1

Joe Colaleo as Young Daniel's Friend #2

Riley Irvin as Young Daniel's Friend #3

Cecilia Okoye as Guard #1

David Opegbemi as Guard #2

Jancey Sheats as News Reporter

Craig Cole as Police Officer #2 (uncredited)

Braden Balazik as Detention Center Kid (uncredited)

Angela Destro as Detention Center Doctor (uncredited)

Riley Fitzgerald as Juvenile Detention Kid (uncredited)

Isaiah Finley as Detention Guard (uncredited)