Jared Harris as Stan Deen

Nicholas Hamilton as Nathan Williams

Jamie Harris as Barney

Sasha Bhasin as Tina Baxter

Will Price as Johnny Alecco

Kimberly S. Fairbanks as Deborah May

Tobias Segal as Nate's Father

Martin Jarvis as Henry V (voice)

Brandon Miles as Barnaby

Johnathan Davis as Officer Smits

Daisy Galvis as Judge

Scottie DiGiacomo as Mother

Banks Quinney as Young Nathan

Elise Hudson as Linda

Meredith Sullivan as Gloria

Niva Patel as Jen

Gwyneth Anne Trumbore as Orphan

Shannon Destiny Ryan as Young Woman Annabel

Searra Sawka as Rona

Ava Wrubel as Pastor's Daughter

Sung Yoon as Carl

Kiley Lotz as Sandy

Cole Tristan Murphy as Noah

Chris James Boylan as Blake

Carol Florence as Nanny Cole

Rachel Poletick as Terry

Collin Roach as Travis

L. J. Moses as Cellmate

Kathy Patterson as Older Woman

Lauren LoGiudice as Attorney

Ernest DiLullo Sr. as Prison Guard

Kendra Mittermeyer as Neighbor

Cole Flanders as Orphan

Phillip Chorba as Tom Friedman

Susanne Sulby as Mariam Baker

Vann Barrett as Booking Officer

Joey Cabrera as Jim Baxter

Madalyn St. John as Mrs. Feeney

Pat DeFusco as Principal Larson

Madeleine Garcia as Lisa

Brian Foreman as Teacher

Johny Walsh as Nurse 1

Nicolai Kabana as High School Student

Michael Harrah as Grandpa Cole

Sebastian Coates as Bruce

Derek Larthey as Prison Guard

AJ Rhoads as Track Teammate

Stan Kang as Mr. Sullivan

Evyn Flanders as Orphan

Lillian Haverty as Orphan

Hasan Mustafic as Bobby

Chuck Pressler as Paramedic #1

Morris Davis as Detective

Kylee Anne Agnello as Theatre Student

Sammy Lynne Toth as High School Student

Emilyanne Cusato as Carol

Lyndsey Bentham as Student / Party Girl

Alexander Ramirez as Party Teen

Lisa Sponaugle as Mrs. Sullivan

Cathy Ritter as Student

Rodney Jones as Attorney

Madison Frye as Track Meet Spectator

Michael Jansen as Officer Spellen

Michael Thomas Ford as Police Officer

Nancy Marron-Asti as Viola

Matt R Stover as Student

Safiyah Brown as Orphan

Gwendolyn Varley as Orphan

Luke Simons as Student

Ashleigh Sites as Theater Student

Cherie Klenieski as High School Student

Alyssa Frye as Track Meet Spectator

Wendy Staton as Regina

Steve 'Stevieweevie' Jones as Track Meet Parent

Melissa Cotter as Track Student Parent (uncredited)

Joseph Giambrone as Baker (uncredited)

Gina Jun as Nurse (uncredited)

Lois Sach as Grocery Store Deli Personnel (uncredited)

Tim R. Worley as Parent (uncredited)