Charlie Day as Peter

Jenny Slate as Emma Moore

Scott Eastwood as Noah

Gina Rodriguez as Anne

Manny Jacinto as Logan

Clark Backo as Ginny

Luke David Blumm as Trevor

Mason Gooding as Paul

Dylan Gelula as Lisa

Isabel May as Leighton

Pete Davidson as Jase

Giselle Torres as Chloe

Quinn Cooke as Taylor

Claudia Rocafort as Sylvia

Kysen Acevedo as Toby

Jami Gertz as Rita

Lauren Halperin as Janine

Thy Bui as Matt

Braxton Alexander as Middle School Boyfriend

Betsy Sligh as Middle School Girlfriend

Franco Castan as Audience Member

Jessi Goei as Waiter

Saya Watkins as Audrey

Manny Magnus as Seymour

Marco Schittone as Dentist

Polly Craig as Old Woman

Lynne Ashe as Receptionist

Yannis Kitas as Stage Manager

Ben McKenzie as Leighton's Dad

Spencer Murrill as Plant

Austin Seifert as Atlanto Bro #2

Kenneth Rouché as Pastor

Ava Ann Gale as Playground Kid (uncredited)

Chloe Camp as Birthday Party Kid

Linda D Gaines as Bar Patron (uncredited)

Julian Williams as Atlanta Bro #2