Sarah Lieving as Kelly

Jeff Denton as Phil Jenkins

Thomas Downey as Quinn McKenzie

Joel Ezra Hebner as The Creature / Ray Loubes

Tom Nagel as Billy Loubes

Noel Thurman as Pamela Fitske

Maija Polsley as June Brown

Matt Kawczynski as Dennis Snarski

Dan Tana as Zeke Loubes

George Williams as Father Rogers

Bernadette Pérez as Gina Germaine

Anne Apra as Mrs. Van Beek

Kyle Kaplan as Jeff Van Beek

Mark Womack as Timmy

Christina Rosenberg as Sandy Brown

Heather Conforto as Gretchin Willings

Amanda Barton as Shelly Berka

Andrew Lauer as Jack Berka

Eliza Swenson as Tami

Steven C. Miller as Brad Willson / Bar Patron

Kean Cronin as George Krantz

William Clevinger as Victor

Kurt Altschwager as Farmer Barton

Jennifer Black as Dyana Stacy

Jill McGrady as Mrs. Lewis

Hutchi Hancock as Maddy Mann

Derek Riley as Pat McGuire

Megan Bass-Jackson as Sheila