Colin Hanks as Ben Keller

Ari Graynor as Lucy St. Martin

Ann-Margret as Pauline Keller

Jeffrey Tambor as Detective Harold Waylon

Adam J. Harrington as Steve Mason

Mimi Rogers as Ms. Brand

Allison Mackie as Grace

Tom Amandes as Jonathan

Michelle Davidson as Leslie Singer

Olivia Sather as Shannon

Eric Kirchberger as Sunny Mart Clerk

Heather Marie Marsden as Allison

Bryan McClure as Sandwich Guy

Bennett Wright as 8 year old Ben

Lena Noel Krussel as 8 year old Lucy

Thom Sibbitt as Mechanic

Jill Peterson as Woman

Cullen Chollett as Man

Virginia Kincaid as Another Woman

Ryle Smith as Another Man

Michael Arata as Man with Piña Colada

Olivia N. Johnson as Woman Eating Cheese Fingers

Sean Modica as Chip

Angelea Jenson as Female Anchor

Patrick Combs as Male Anchor

Jeanne Averill as Sales Lady

Bernie Clark as Older Man

Kay Clark as Older Woman

Meghan Strange as Woman Eating Celery Sticks

Leanne Hill Carlson as Shanna

Elizabeth Uhl as Stephanie

Robert W. Baker as Sunny Mart Manager

Samantha Gutstadt as Dark Haired Woman

Dana Daurey as Wendy

Matt Harwell as Reporter #1

Michelle Schrage as Reporter #2

Jason Harris as Radio DJ