Jennifer Garner as Cindy Green

Joel Edgerton as Jim Green

CJ Adams as Timothy Green

Odeya Rush as Joni Jerome

Shohreh Aghdashloo as Evette Onat

Rosemarie DeWitt as Brenda Best

David Morse as James Green, Sr.

Ron Livingston as Franklin Crudstaff

Dianne Wiest as Ms. Bernice Crudstaff

M. Emmet Walsh as Uncle Bub

Lois Smith as Aunt Mel

Lin-Manuel Miranda as Reggie

William J. Harrison as Bobby Crudstaff

James Rebhorn as Joseph Crudstaff

Common as Coach Cal

Patrick Brouder as Dash Best

Chan Creswell as Billy CrudStaff

Shimei Bailey as Little Boy in Elevator

Michael Arden as Doug Wert

Rhoda Griffis as Doctor Lesley Hunt

Karan Kendrick as Mother at Doctor's Office

Kendall Ryan Sanders as Rod Best

Judy Langford as Ms. Crudstaff's Assistant

Michael Beasley as Cop

Cullen Moss as Cop

Gene Jones as Neighbor

Jason Davis as Bart Best

Lucy Gebhardt as Bethany Best

Sharon Conley as Principal Morrison

Dorothy Vollmer as Trixie Crudstaff

Dwayne Boyd as Ref

Mattie Liptak as #8

Jay Freer as Coach Bob Francesconi

Tim Ware as Mayor Handelman

Susan Bruce as Molly Frohn

Tara Lee as Nurse

Joe Crosson as Factory Worker

Tim Guinee as Marty Rader (voice)

Shaun O'Banion as Alan Rust (voice)