Gene Tierney as Belle Starr

Randolph Scott as Sam Starr

Dana Andrews as Thomas Crail

Shepperd Strudwick as Ed Shirley

Elizabeth Patterson as Sarah

Chill Wills as Blue Duck

Louise Beavers as Mammy Lou

Olin Howland as Jasper Trench

Paul E. Burns as Sergeant

Joe Sawyer as John Cole

Joe Downing as Jim Cole

Howard Hickman as Colonel Thornton

Charles Trowbridge as Colonel Bright

James Flavin as Sergeant

Charles Middleton as Carpetbagger

Herbert Ashley as Jailer (uncredited)

Hooper Atchley as Carpetbagger

Matthew Beard as Young Jake (uncredited)

Hugh Chapman as Tench's Son (uncredited)

Davison Clark as Bartender (uncredited)

Mary Currier as Dressmaker (uncredited)

Franklyn Farnum as Barfly (uncredited)

Edward Fielding as Undetermined Secondary Role (uncredited)

Avanelle Harris as Dressed-up Freed Slave (uncredited)

Dolores Hurlic as Jake's Granddaughter (uncredited)

Mae Marsh as Preacher's Wife (uncredited)

Kermit Maynard as Union Officer (uncredited)

George Melford as Preacher (uncredited)

Juanita Moore as Dressed-up Freed Slave (uncredited)

Adrian Morris as Major Grail's Orderly (uncredited)

Clarence Muse as Bootblack in Saloon (uncredited)

George H. Reed as Old Jake (uncredited)

Clinton Rosemond as Black Man on Bench (uncredited)

Elena Verdugo as Young Girl (uncredited)

Billy Wayne as Soldier (uncredited)

Cecil Weston as Mother (uncredited)

Norman Willis as Union Corporal (uncredited)