Judd Nelson as Pastor Wember

Brian Baumgartner as Skip Wick

Rhoda Griffis as Donna

Claire Bronson as Rebekah

Shawn Parsons as Chris Angelopolous

Gunner Willis as Cliff

Shua Jackson as Roadie

Michael H. Cole as Jack

Sandra Elise Williams as Mimi

Jef Holbrook as Snarky Fan

Andrew Eakle as Erik

Caleb Hoffmann as Scotty

Shannon Hutchinson as Sarah

Wyatt Lenhart as Michael

Matt Hoffman as Adult Erik

Blaque Fowler as Drunk Rocker

Alan Wells as Perry Minter

Lilly Nelson as Meg

Christina Leidel as Amy Grant

James Edward Thomas as Adult Cliff

Miles Snow as Dean Wilkie

Pete Penuel as Adult Michael

Laticia Lee as Bartender

Sean Freeland as Kasper Kapelrud