Laura Osnes as Anna Jordan

Aaron Tveit as James Galant

Krystal Joy Brown as Sarah Melnick

Tom McGowan as Ed Jordan

Victoria Clark as Gabriella Galant

Bradley Rose as Christopher Brooks

Geraldine Leer as Diane

Josiah Harvey as Ball Guest

Chengusoyane Kargbo as Nurse

Frances McGarry as Mrs. Maitlin

Jerry Kernion as Driver

Will Child as Santa

Kerry McGann as Local Woman Carrie

Ian Lyons as Musician

J.P. Giuliotti as Donny's Clerk

Derrick Davis as MC

Erika Santosuosso as Clerk

Anne Rutter as Wife