Josh Katawick as Nicholas Hollyhock / Lance Hollyhock

Katie Mitchell as Katie Marie Francesca

Kate Wilford as Monica Sweetmaker

Daniel Britt as Cosmo Lambini

Geoffrey Barnes as Father McAdams

Landon Mergler as Jimmy

Johanna McGinley as Margee

Katie Groneman as Joan

Ben Jacobs as Jack

Becca Howell as Grace

Amy Barbian as Sophie

Ray Dzhorgov as Boris

Rory Sheridan as Philip

Jeremy Dubin as Alberto / Alphonse

Matthieu Charbonneau as Waiter

Nathan Flesh as Grateful Patron

Rio O'Neal as Urchin

Tony Moorman as Neighbor

Ted Weil as Jogger

Keating P. Sharp as 7-Year Old Boy

Jared Hudson as Bank Customer 1

Allen Middleton as Bank Customer 2

Jared Doren as Bank Customer 3

Tony Million as Bank Security Guard

Justin McCombs as Policeman

Maggie Lou Rader as Driver 1

Bob Gerding as Driver 2

Darnell Benjamin as Driver 3

Emily Seibert as Driver 4

Billy Chace as Homeless Guy

Jenny McManus as Church Attendee

Shawn P. Farrell as Holiday Shopper (uncredited)