Ryan Wesley Gilreath as Tony Mirakul

Annie Kalahurka as Amana Davenport Mirakul

Laura E. Mock as Emily Vanderslice Seacker

Chris Petty as Joseph Seacker

Victoria McDevitt as Jessie Seacker

Michael Shawn Starks as Simon Wasp a.k.a. Doug Dineen

Sean Cook as Deacon Blue

Christine Jones as Sister Mary Rose

Raymond A. Smith as Father Stan Pacific

Larry Cole as Father Nicholas Barkley

David Baum as Father Leonard Defazio 'Fr. Def'

A. John Beeler as Magician

Arizona Craycraft as Rachel Brony

Lindsey Marlin as Nurse Abby

Tom Morton as Father O'Toole

Mitch Teemley as Archbishop Jonathan Seemley

Mike Haley as Man at Bar

Ryley Emory-Hays as Student 'Mary'

Kameron Laguna as Student 'Gabriel'

Danny Rigney as Limo Driver

Daphne Steele as Toddler

Thomas W. Wenz as Father of the Bride

Rosemary Wenz as Mother of the Bride