Tom Welling as Nick Castle

Maggie Grace as Elizabeth Williams

Selma Blair as Stevie Wayne

DeRay Davis as Spooner

Kenneth Welsh as Tom Malone

Adrian Hough as Father Robert Malone

Sara Botsford as Kathy Williams

Cole Heppell as Andy Wayne

Mary Black as Aunt Connie

Jonathon Young as Dan The Weatherman

R. Nelson Brown as Machen

Rade Šerbedžija as Captain William Blake

Matthew Currie Holmes as Sean Castle

Sonja Bennett as Mandi

Meghan Heffern as Brandi / Jennifer

Douglas Arthurs as Founding Father David Williams

Christian Bocher as Founding Father Patrick Malone

Charles Andre as Founding Father Norman Castle

Yves Cameron as Founding Father Richard Wayne

Robert Harper as Mr. Latham

Alex Bruhanski as Uncle Hank

Dan Shea as Fisherman

Rick Pearce as Fisherman

Eric Breker as Sheriff's Deputy

Stefan Arngrim as Blake's Compadre

Steven Cree Molison as Local Fisherman

Xantha Radley as Mother in Hold

August Winter as Child in Hold

Tatiana Turner as Woman in Hold

John Destry as Man in Hold