Jon Hamm as Chief Jordan Sanders

Tina Fey as Rita Grace

Micah Stock as Jay Moore

Nick Mohammed as Deputy KB Reddy

Happy Anderson as Kosco

Louisa Krause as Maggie Moore

Mary Holland as Maggie Lee Moore

Derek Basco as Tommy T

Christopher Denham as Andy Moore

Tate Ellington as Duane Rich

Allison Dunbar as Stephanie

Debrianna Mansini as Professor Brody

Oona Roche as Sammi

Frederick Branch as Patrolman Foley

Nicholas Azarian as Greg

Bobbi Kitten as Cassie Novak

Kristin K. Berg as Shelly

Roni Geva as Sandy Ritter

Lauren Pool as Gwen

Christopher Kriesa as Jerry Connors

Claire Hinkley as Allison

Denielle Fisher Johnson as ME Lucy Adler

Bryant Carroll as Tony Carlson

Peter Diseth as Phillips

Sewell Whitney as Peter Rice

John Forbes as Benson

Jodi Lynn Thomas as Jodi aka Cocktail Waitress

Richard Lippert as Pastor Roberts

Chance Romero as Jerry Nutter

Gabriela Alicia Ortega as Stripper

Emmanualle Sale Taylor as Buddy

Jeff Allen as Officer Ross