Julie Harris as Sister Anthony

Andrew McCarthy as Richard Reilly

Trini Alvarado as Beth

Jessica Hecht as Sister Mary

Shannon Holt as Sister Lucia 1939

Betty Aberlin as Sister Sarah

Anne Pitoniak as Mother Superior Francis

Imogene Bliss as Sister Lucia 1996

Nili Bassman as Anna 1950

Lulee Fisher as Sister Rose

Lynne Innerst as Sister Francis 1939

Therese Courtney as Mother Superior 1939

Suzi Hofrichter as Anna 1939

Kathleen McEntee as Sister Margaret

Chad Luberger as Roy

Zachary Mott as Anna's Father

Beverly Owings as Matron

Collin Quinn as Tom

Katherine Sweeney as Terry

David Whalen as Sven

Cornell J. Wallace as Harvey

Jaime Shapiro as Doreen