Michael Urie as Peter

Philemon Chambers as Nick

Luke Macfarlane as James

Jennifer Coolidge as Aunt Sandy

Kathy Najimy as Carole

Jennifer Robertson as Lisa

Barry Bostwick as Harold

Madison Brydges as Daniela

Alexandra Beaton as Sofia

Dan Finnerty as Kevin

Steve Lund as Tim

Melanie Leishman as Ashleigh

Gryffin Hanvelt as Simon

Stefano DiMatteo as Tony

Victor Andres Trelles Turgeon as Jim

Rachel Mutombo as Pasadena Mom

Adam Capriolo as Adam

Christopher Hayes as Philip

Matt Keyes as Josh

Marvin Ishmael as Victor

Max Emerson as Influencer

Kyle Krieger as Influencer

Hasani Freeman as Boy #1

Christina Filippidis as Mrs. Claus

Viggo Hanvelt as Sam

David Baby as House Owner

Michael Mast as Construction Guy