Max Ehrich as Samuel Allen

Katelyn Nacon as Julie Ledbetter

J. Alphonse Nicholson as Barry

Emma Myers as Angie Blackburn

Gary Weeks as Joe Allen

Justice Leak as T.L. Whittmore

Braxton Bjerken as Jesse

Beau Hart as Young Samuel Allen

Liam Pileggi as Little Samuel Allen

Friedman Twinkies as Young Jesse

Burgess Jenkins as Tony Jacks

Alex Sgambati as Edith

Justin Miles as Deputy Skinner

Jeffrey A. Smith as Pastor Claybourn

Frank Hoyt Taylor as Bishop Bannister Whittmore

Ric Reitz as Dr. Wade Blackburn

Alpha Trivette as Judge

David Alexander as Brother Dylan

Christian Finlayson as Ray Ledbetter