Tad Hilgenbrink as Matt Stifler

Arielle Kebbel as Elyse

Jason Earles as Ernie

Crystle Lightning as Chloe

Jun Hee Lee as Jimmy

Omar Benson Miller as Oscar

Chris Owen as Sherman

Eugene Levy as Mr. Levenstein

Ginger Lynn Allen as Nurse Sanders

Lauren C. Mayhew as Arianna

Matt Barr as Brandon Vandecamp

Timothy Stack as Mr. Nelson

Angela Little as Sheree

Rachel Veltri as Dani

Matt T. Baker as Derek

Dossett Marchese as Andy

Russell W. Howard as Riggler

Carla Alapont as Leslie

Lily Mariye as Dr. Susan Choi

Jim Jackman as Principal Vegas

Tara Killian as Patti

Jennifer Walcott as Laurie

Claire Titelman as Claire

Kathleen LaGue as Robards Receptionist

Colleen McDermott as Elyse's Mom

Daniel Booko as Senior Football Player

Judy Busey as Ernie's Mother

Micah Alberti as Football Player

Brandon Irons as Football Player

Michael Lawson as Bootleg Bandy

Richard Keith as Trading Card Bandy

Adam Wylie as Trading Card Bandy

Jennifer McMahon as Dancer

Joelle Cosentino as Dancer

Lizzy Richardson as Dancer

Heather Miller as Dancer

Jean-Paul DiFranco as Guitar Player