Anna Kendrick as Sheryl Bradshaw

Daniel Zovatto as Rodney Alcala

Nicolette Robinson as Laura

Autumn Best as Amy

Pete Holmes as Terry

Kelley Jakle as Sarah

Kathryn Gallagher as Charlie

Tony Hale as Ed

Matt Visser as Bachelor #1

Jedidiah Goodacre as Bachelor #2

Rob Morton as Custodian (George Elliot)

Dylan Schmid as Mario

Karen Holness as Gretchen

Denalda Williams as Marilyn

Jessie Fraser as Lisa

Matty Finochio as Casting Director

Geoff Gustafson as Casting Director

Max Lloyd-Jones as Ken

Andy Thompson as Bob

Nancy Kerr as Diane

James Yi as Joe

Jessica Chaffin as Helen

Matthew Kevin Anderson as Mark

Taylor Hastings as Melanie

David Beairsto as Rodney's Boss

Darcy Laurie as Marty

Marc Gaudet as Head Mover

Bonnie Hay as Bartender

Michael Adamthwaite as Dating Game Director

Jacob Woike as Dating Game 1st Assistant Director

Jason Simpson as Dating Game Announcer

Hannah Henney as Bachelorette (Playback)

Tighe Gill as Bachelor (Playback)

Michael Jonsson as Booth Security Guard (Harold)

Vonnie Bennetto as Typist

Thomas Strumpski as Laundromat Owner

John Herkenrath as Detective

Jeremy Radin as Detective

Cody Heller as Alison