Kiersey Clemons as Susie

Alex Wolff as Jesse

Jim Gaffigan as Sheriff Loggins

Ken Marino as Edgar Cabot

David Walton as Deputy Graham

Isaac Powell as Ray Garcia

Rachel Sennott as Jillian

Geoffrey Owens as President Andrews

Alex Moffat as Hayden Powers

Dolly Wells as Professor Gallagher

Kat Foster as Dianne Seleck

Jared Gilman as Jed

Neal Bledsoe as Brady Wren

Aaron Costa Ganis as Tad Bickel

Juliette Goglia as Ryan Sims

McKenna Quigley Harrington as Aimee

Mellanie Hubert as Sally Lynch

Ana Cruz Kayne as Misty Consuelos

Ellie Reine as Young Suzie

Jammie Patton as Anne

Chris Sheffield as Henrique The Trainer