Parker Posey as Susan Felders

Eric Mabius as Pete Cozy

Annie Parisse as Sara Biltmore-Cozy

Finn Donoghue as Henry Cozy

Matt Servitto as Jim Brady

Victor Cruz as Dave Scalzod

Josh Pais as Doug Cain

Amy Schumer as Lila

Brian Berrebbi as Matt Davis

Xosha Roquemore as Donna

Samrat Chakrabarti as Eddie

Matt Walker as Tony Gomes

Remy Auberjonois as Todd Kenner

Mylinda Hull as Daphne's Mother

Marceline Hugot as Mrs. Raphael

Edward Herrmann as Jack Bennington

Faith Sandberg as Bennington's Assistant

Juan Luis Acevedo as Salesman

Frank Amoruso as Company Board Member

Jayce Bartok as Bobby McCain

Natalie Best as Clara the Bartender

Julia Bray as Cheryl

Teena Byrd as Restaurant Guest

Joseph D'Onofrio as Town car driver

Stephen Kunken as Cartwright

Steve Park as Board Member

Jennifer Mudge as Janis

John Fugelsang as Jake

Cheyenne Jackson as Ernie

Dean Wareham as Himself

Britta Phillips as Herself

Shea Curtin as Daphne

Elle Donoghue as Preschool Student

Christopher Douros as Donald

Selena Mars as Lady in Silver

Nicholas Martorell Jr. as Syd

Elizabeth Masucci as Waitress

Leslie C. Nemet as Restaurant Guest

Mike O'Brien as Board Member

Meghan Anne Riley as Bar Patron

Nate Steinwachs as Patrick

Isaac Wilson as Preschool Boy

A.J. Wladyka as Preschool Student