Gina Rodriguez as Mack

Damon Wayans Jr. as Adam

Tom Ellis as Nick Russell

Augustus Prew as Brannagan

Joel Courtney as Ryan 'Little'

Liza Koshy as Ashley

Jerry Kernion as Carl

Ego Nwodim as Claire

Marin Hinkle as Kirk

Brock O'Hurn as Brady Stratton

Gina Jun as VIP Gala Guest

Kais Boukthir as Super Fan

Sterling Jonatán Williams as Tattoo Librarian

Darron Jay Morgan as Holiday Party D.J.

Dan Cordle as Kirk's Husband

Claudia Maree Mailer as Kourtney Martini

George J. Vezina as Sal Greenberg

Scottie DiGiacomo as Rich woman at Gala

Sarah Dacey Charles as Mary

James Hightower as Bartender #2

Veraalba Santa as Waitress

Tony Foggia as Ticket Taker