Alison Brie as Ally

Jay Ellis as Sean

Kiersey Clemons as Cassidy

Danny Pudi as Benny

Haley Joel Osment as Jeremy

Amy Sedaris as Deedee

Julie Hagerty as Libby

Olga Merediz as Joanne 'JoJo'

Evan Jonigkeit as Chef Jamie

Ayden Mayeri as Kayla

Jeanine Jackson as Grace

Hannah Barefoot as Michelle

Kelvin Yu as Christian

Rachel Pate as Teresa

Ted Rooney as Barry

Zoë Chao as Ramona

Sam Richardson as Dar

Jeb Berrier as Mike

Fabi Reyna as Jules