Ray Milland as Vernon Simpson

Jean Peters as Deborah Greenleaf

Paul Douglas as Monk Lanigan

Ed Begley as Edgar Stone

Ted de Corsia as Jimmy Dolan

Ray Collins as Alfred Greenleaf

Jessie Royce Landis as Mrs. Greenleaf

Alan Hale Jr. as Schmidt

Kathleen Hughes as Sarah (uncredited)

Mae Marsh as Greenleaf's Maid (uncredited)

Debra Paget as Alice (uncredited)

Ray Teal as Mac (uncredited)

William Murphy as Tommy Isbell

Robert Adler as Reporter (uncredited)

Baird Allington as Baseball Player (uncredited)

Ward Brant as Baseball Player (uncredited)

John Butler as Fan Visiting with Debbie (uncredited)

Johnny Calkins as Boy Sitting Next to Debbie at Ballpark (uncredited)

Harry Carter as Baseball Fan in Stands (uncredited)

Bill Cartledge as Newsboy (uncredited)

Harry Cheshire as Team Doctor X-Raying King's Hand (uncredited)

Pat Combs as Telegram Delivery Boy (uncredited)

Al Eben as Parker - Team Trainer (uncredited)

Gene Evans as Batter Mueller (uncredited)

Sandra Gould as Mabel on Telephone (voice) (uncredited)

William E. Green as Prof. Joe Forsythe (uncredited)

Tom Hanlon as St. Louis Broadcaster (uncredited)

Sam Hayes as New York Broadcaster (uncredited)

Don Hicks as Assistant to New York Announcer (uncredited)

Edward Keane as Jack Bell (uncredited)

Kenner G. Kemp as Baseball Fan (uncredited)

Ruth Lee as Miss Collins - Prof. Greenleaf's Secretary (uncredited)

Joseph R. Liscio as Trainer (uncredited)

Lee MacGregor as Student (uncredited)

John McKee as Baseball Player (uncredited)

George Melford as Conductor (uncredited)

Billy Mitchell as Sweeper Outside Carob Hotel (uncredited)

Debra Paget as Alice - College Co-ed (uncredited)

Robert Patten as Cab Driver (uncredited)

Ed Randolph as Umpire (uncredited)

Grandon Rhodes as Professor (uncredited)

Harry Seymour as Jewelry Store Clerk (uncredited)

Mickey Simpson as Stadium Policeman (uncredited)

Douglas Spencer as Train Conductor (uncredited)

Bert Stevens as Man in Train Station (uncredited)

Brick Sullivan as Umpire (uncredited)

Jane Van Duser as Miss Mengalstein - Dolan's Secretary (uncredited)

Max Wagner as Umpire (uncredited)

Robert B. Williams as Reporter (uncredited)

Charles Flynn as Reporter (uncredited)