Mel Gibson as Gene Carruthers

Mason Thames as Noah Reed

Julian Lerner as Eugene Wexler

Abigail James Witherspoon as Sammy Devers

Noah Cottrell as Ben Driskel

Nora Zehetner as Abby Reed

Lorraine Bracco as Miss Halverson

Emma Fasano as Lilly Reed

Spencer Fitzgerald as Ronnie Harlow

Patrick Renna as Umpire

Ashley Rae Trisler as Witch

Gavin Bedell as Kevin Lampkey

Gary Weeks as Chief Hartley

Bobbi Baker as Hannah Driskel

Kelly Collins Lintz as Deb Harlow

Nico Tirozzi as Little Boy / Carruthers' Son

Lilah Pate as Ellie Evans

Kevin James as Edgar Palmer

Barbara Goodson as The Witch (voice)

Abrielle Josephine Cincotti as Emily

Nick Benas as Baseball Fan (uncredited)

Parker E. Chick as Town Kid (uncredited)

Sara Elizabeth Ezzell as Diner Patron / Pedestrian (uncredited)

Robert Fortunato as Police Officer (uncredited)

Keeley Kollmann as Mom with Kids (uncredited)

Samantha Miro as Jogger (uncredited)

Art Newkirk as Dad in Theater (uncredited)

Logan Newkirk as Book Signing Kid (uncredited)

Violet Berlus as Skip-It Girl

Lara Fontes as Lilly (voice)

Hannah Michelle as Pedestrian

Mary Clare Mitchell as Diner Patron

Lucretia Newkirk as Tourist

David Pascua as Police Officer

Veronica Russell as Baseball Spectator

Stacey Stewart as Carruthers' Wife

James Richard Wemmitt as Camera Man