Warner Baxter as Joaquin Murrieta

Ann Loring as Señorita Juanita de la Cuesta

Bruce Cabot as Bill Warren

Margo as Rosa F. 'Rosita' de Murrieta

J. Carrol Naish as Three Fingered Jack

Soledad Jiménez as Madre Murrieta

Carlos De Valdez as José Murrieta

Eric Linden as Johnnie 'Jack' Warren

Edgar Kennedy as Sheriff Judd

Charles Trowbridge as Ramon de la Cuesta

Harvey Stephens as Capt. Osborne

Ralph Remley as Judge Hank Perkins

George Regas as Tomás

Francis McDonald as Pedro

Kay Hughes as Louise

Paul Hurst as Wilson

Boothe Howard as Tabbard

Harry Woods as Pete

Earl Douglas as Julio Anton

Sam Ash as Arriga

Hank Bell as Posse Man

Dick Botiller as Pancho

Frank Campeau as Coach Driver Steve

G. Pat Collins as Doc

Mathilde Comont as Señora Matinez

Pedro de Cordoba as Hacendado Wanting to Cooperate

Richard Cramer as Bartender

Nigel De Brulier as Padre at Wedding (uncredited)

Nick De Ruiz as Peón

Joe Dominguez as Bandit

Al Ferguson as Miner

Harold Goodwin as Slocum

Duke Green as Guerrera

Frank Hagney as Deputy Phil

Lew Harvey as Bill Young

Herbert Heywood as Hacendado Wanting to Fight

Si Jenks as Miner

Marc Lawrence as Manuel

George MacQuarrie as Smithers

J.P. McGowan as Danglong

Ivan Miller as Marshal

Carlotta Monti as Dancer

Tom Moore as Sheriff Hannan

Inez Palange as Nurse with Madre

Bob Perry as Miner at Grave

Lee Phelps as Off-Key Singer Hank

Pérez as Dancer

Pedro Regas as Lookout Yelling 'Murrietta Comes!'

Cully Richards as Juan

Jason Robards Sr. as Pancho

Lee Shumway as Deputy

Charles Stevens as Wedding Guest / Bandit

Ben Taggart as Rancher

Lucio Villegas as

Morgan Wallace as Hacendado Wanting to Fight

Gayne Whitman as

Elizabeth Wilbur as

Frank Yaconelli as Peón

Bob Burns as Miner