Henry Fonda as Gil Carter

Dana Andrews as Donald Martin

Mary Beth Hughes as Rose Mapen/Rose Swanson

Anthony Quinn as Juan Martínez/Francisco Morez

William Eythe as Gerald Tetley

Harry Morgan as Art Croft

Jane Darwell as Ma Grier

Matt Briggs as Judge Daniel Tyler

Harry Davenport as Arthur Davies

Frank Conroy as Maj. Tetley

Marc Lawrence as Jeff Farnley

Paul Hurst as Monty Smith

Victor Kilian as Darby

Chris-Pin Martin as Poncho

Willard Robertson as Sheriff Risley

Ted North as Joyce

C.E. Anderson as Posse Member (uncredited)

Stanley Andrews as Bartlett (uncredited)

Hank Bell as Red (uncredited)

William Benedict as Greene (uncredited)

Paul E. Burns as Winder (uncredited)

George Chandler as Jimmy Carnes (uncredited)

Tex Cooper as Posse Member (uncredited)

Forrest Dillon as Mark (uncredited)

Dan Dix as Posse Member (uncredited)

Larry Dods as Posse Member (uncredited)

Tex Driscoll as Posse Member (uncredited)

Francis Ford as Alva 'Dad' Hardwicke (uncredited)

Margaret Hamilton as Mrs. Larch (uncredited)

Rondo Hatton as Gabe Hart (uncredited)

Don House as Posse Member (uncredited)

George Lloyd as Moore (uncredited)

Tom London as Deputy (uncredited)

Frank McGrath as Posse Member (uncredited)

George Meeker as Mr. Swanson (uncredited)

Frank Orth as Larry Kinkaid (uncredited)

George Plues as Alec Small (uncredited)

Dick Rich as Deputy Butch Mapes (uncredited)

Ed Richard as Posse Member (uncredited)

Walt Robbins as Posse Member (uncredited)

Almira Sessions as Miss Swanson (uncredited)

Clint Sharp as Posse Member (uncredited)

Ben Watson as Posse Member (uncredited)

Leigh Whipper as Sparks (uncredited)