Dax Shepard as John Lyshitski

Will Arnett as Nelson Biederman IV

Chi McBride as Barry

David Koechner as Shanahan

Dylan Baker as Warden

Michael Shannon as Lynard

Miguel Nino as Jesus

Jay Whittaker as Icepick

Amy Hill as Judge Eva Fwae Wun

David Darlow as Judge Biederman

Joseph Marcus as Pawn Broker

Nick Phalen as John (8 years)

A.J. Balance as John (18 years)

Jerry Minor as Breen Guard

Mary Seibel as Old Bartender

Susan Messing as Stripper

Jim Zulevic as Sgt. Barker

Bill McGough as Deputy Mayor

Bob Odenkirk as Duane

Bert Matias as Korean Pharmacist

Salome St. Clair as Mingha

Jordan Teplitz as Board Member #1

Richard Bull as Board Member #2

Mark Morettini as Bailiff

Llou Johnson as Black Juror

Nathan Davis as Old Juror

Hans Holsen as Cowboy Juror

Dana Leone Hildreth as Punk Juror

Brad Berenson as Prosecutor

Maureen Steindler as Old Woman

Larry Neumann Jr. as Derek

Anthony Lee Irons as Reggie

Bradley Grant Smith as Randy

Ramses Jimenez as Latino Dude #1

Eduardo N. Martinez as Latino Dude #2

Brian Jenkins as Guard #6

Jimmy Kissane as Commissary Guard

Matt Furlin as Prisoner #4

Ellis Foster as Cafeteria Worker

Scott Philyaw as Chubby Prisoner

Laurent Crawford as Visitation Guard

Manny Sosa as Mexican Convict

Robert Gerdisch as Billy

Rich Wilkie as Young Guard

Drew Hastings as The Mule

Sue Gillan as Teacher

Ripper Brown as Tough Prisoner

Joe Nuñez as Prisoner in Bathroom

Peter Burns as Parole Board Head

Claudia Michelle Wallace as Parole Board Member

Arraon Skippa Hixson as Prisoner #1

Craig J. Harris as Guard #8

Ed Smaron as Guard #7

Theron Touché Lykes as Prisoner #3

Tony De Leon as Prisoner #2

Mick Napier as Coroner

Michael Hitchcock as Wine Taster

Tim Heidecker as Wine Taster (uncredited)

Eric Wareheim as Wine Taster (uncredited)