Luke Evans as Nicky

Billy Porter as Gabriel

Christopher Woodley as Owen

Andrew Rannells as Matthew

Robin Weigert as Pam

Kate Burton as Maggie "Miggie"

Phylicia Rashād as Maya

Isaac Powell as Solo

Michael Countryman as Jim "Grumps"

David Pittu as Ian

Cassandra Freeman as Adele

Gabby Beans as Judith

Liza J. Bennett as Claire

Nuala Cleary as Isabella

Francis Jue as Jason

Alfredo Narciso as Lorenzo

William DeMeritt as Will

Kerry Warren as Jennifer

Aurora Richards as Sophie

Will Coombs as Max Jr.

Emily Donahoe as Alexandra

Ramsey Faragallah as Judge Reynolds

Gil Perez-Abraham as Kevin

John Wollman as Principal Howard

Bryan Terrell Clark as Jacob

Kaimi Glover as Youth Center Receptionist

Fran Thomas as Club Bartender

Amber Valentine as Club DJ

Tkeyah Thurman as Club DJ

Cyler Daigle as Solo's Friend