Judy Greer as Janice LaRue

Alexander Skarsgård as Ron LaRue

Alison Pill as Lisa Graff

Tracy Letts as Bill Verne

Paul Sparks as Steve Calhan

Annie Parisse as Stephanie Grazer

Kate Arrington as Jill Yardling

Nation Sage Henrikson as Eric LaRue

Jacob Alexander as Brad Gilbert

Jennifer Engstrom as Laura Gates

Mierka Girten as Sheila Guffy

Lawrence Grimm as Jack McCoy

David Pasquesi as Documentary Narrator

Sierra Foley as Rachel Fuller

Marylouise Burke as Wilma Kentworthy

Shea Pritchard as Teen #1

Jalen Michael Black as Teen #2

Jaylee Kennedy as Teen #3

Ridge Lewis as Young Victim

Jack Davis as Young Victim

Ryan Sharp as Young Victim

Chevy Lamont Cofield as Correctional Officer (uncredited)

Kareem L. Alston as Officer J. Rose (uncredited)

Ruth Rhett Bennett as Parishioner (uncredited)

Andrew Donovan as Lisa's Husband (uncredited)

Art Newkirk as Correction Officer (uncredited)

Logan Newkirk as Young Eric (uncredited)

Bobbie Peterson as Prison Visitor (uncredited)

William G. Tomek as Corrections Officer (uncredited)