Eliza Scanlen as Jem Starling

Lewis Pullman as Owen Taylor

Wrenn Schmidt as Heidi Starling

Jimmi Simpson as Paul Starling

Claire Elizabeth Green as Rebecca Starling

Austin Abrams as Ben Taylor

Chris Dinner as Noah Starling

Paige Leigh Landers as Kelsey

Kieran Sitawi as Jeremy Starling

Jessamine Burgum as Misty Taylor

Kyle Secor as Pastor Taylor

Andrew Riley Stephens as Mike Stone

K.J. Baker as Anne Abbott

Ellie May as Sarah Starling

Brianna Bronger as Nora

Abby Hobek as Rachel