Sean Patrick Flanery as John

Briana Evigan as Ms. Merrywood

Jessica Lowndes as Tamara

Bill Moseley as The Magician

Dayton Callie as Ticket-Keeper

Paul Sorvino as God

Terrance Zdunich as Lucifer

Alexa PenaVega as Wick

Nivek Ogre as The Twin

Marc Senter as The Scorpion

Emilie Autumn as Painted Doll

Shawn Crahan as The Tamer

J. LaRose as The Major

Ivan L. Moody as Hobo Clown

Tillman Norsworthy as Daniel

Mighty Mike Murga as The Fool

Beach Eastwood as Zombie Clown

Maddisyn Carter as Goth Girl

George Frangadakis as Shadowy Man

Zero Kazama as Fire Welder

Maggie Rose Lally as Woe-Maiden

Hannah "Minx" Wagner as Woe-Maiden

Contessa Montebello as Woe-Maiden

Zach Kasik as Hellharmonic Musician

Shem Andre Byron as Hellharmonic Musician

Laura Meadows as Hellharmonic Musician

Blago Simon as Hellharmonic Musician

Jeff Trenkle as Hellharmonic Musician

Larry L Andrews as Carney

Benjamin Michael Marsh as Carney

Kelly Renee Miller as Carney

Courtney Ortega as Carney

Jackie Zane as Carney

Elvis Dino Esquivel as Juggler (Uncredited)