Ryan Reynolds as George Lutz

Melissa George as Kathy Lutz

Jesse James as Billy Lutz

Jimmy Bennett as Michael Lutz

Chloë Grace Moretz as Chelsea Lutz

Rachel Nichols as Lisa

Philip Baker Hall as Father Callaway

Isabel Conner as Jodie Defeo

Brendan Donaldson as Ronald Defeo

Annabel Armour as Realtor

Rich Komenich as Chief of Police

David Gee as ER Doctor

Danny McCarthy as Officer Greguski

Nancy Lollar as Librarian

José Taitano as Stitch

Lenore Thomas as Nurse Fuller

Marie Joelyn as Store Patron

Dorian Kingi as Scary Leashed Indian

Alan Koeppen as Paramedic

Ryan Kross as Restaurant patron

Sam Raysby as New York State Trooper

Jenny Strubin as Grocery Cashier