Marilyn Oran as Margaret

Zora Iman Crews as Elizabeth

Eric Jay Sonnenschein as Alexander

Amanda Sonnenschein as Girl in Park

Chloe Dykstra as Mel

Leo Camacho as Tom

Skylar Grace Hill as Izzy

Geoff Burt as The Narrator

Amy Geiger as Host (V.O.)

John Geier as Albert Fish

Joseph David Surico as Peter Loring

Bill McAndrews as Philip Libretor

Helen M Glassman as Anna Fish

Steven Wishman as Harrold Aster

Margaret G. Ringwood as Judy Aster

Amanda Durante as Tammy

Bea Maver as Jessica

Matt Sullivan as Mark

Allan Styer as Dr. Weiss

Grannell Knox as Grannell

Hadas Knox as Hadas

Irene Knox as Irene

Grannell Knox, Sr. as Grannell, Sr.

Geoffrey Knox as Geoffrey

Amanda Knox as Amanda

Marie Knox as Marie

Kathy Knox as Kathy

Amos Margulies as Amos

Wilmary Rodriguez as Wilmary

Sheila Dvorak as Sheila

Stephanie Danks as Stephanie

James Danks as James

Jediah Knox as Jediah

River Knox as River

Lily Knox as Lily

Ford Knox as Ford

Natalie Danks as Natalie

Luke Danks as Luke

Richard Rawson as Richard