Kenney Myers as Pastor Luke

Taryn Hacker as Maggie O'Shea

Jon Hacker as Jessie McNeil

Shelby Putlak as Lydia Potter

Mike Rob as Jimmy Capernaum

Colette Prainito as Josi

Owen Dammacco as Tim

Taytem Thomas as Laudine

Al Pagano as Joe McNeil

Allison Mullaney as Abigail (as Allison Mulaney)

Robert Levey II as David

Catherine Cain as Martha

Brooke Capuano as Rachael

Anthony Pallino as John Potter

Kerry Mannix as Simone

Alexandra Sepulveda as Agnes

Gervase Peterson as Uncle Vic

Justin Scheman as Mr. Salem

Jennifer Weinberg-Hancox as Mrs. Salem

London Hancox as Little Samantha

Cara Maria Sorbello as Lucy Horton

Anthony Wilcox as Mr. Lenord

Melanie Little as Aunt Rosie

Connor Kopko as Russ

Cody Calafiore as Jude

Monika Mannix as Bethany