David Howard Thornton as The Mean One

Krystle Martin as Cindy

Chase Mullins as Officer Burke

John Bigham as Doc

Erik Baker as Sheriff Hooper

Amy Schumacher as Mayor McBean

Flip Kobler as Lou

Christopher Sanders as Narrator (voice)

Stephanie Bates as Stephanie

Robert DiTillio as Don

Rachel Winfree as Bartender

Jessie Holder Tourtellotte as Anchorwoman

Allyson Sereboff as Nurse

Saphina Chanadet as Young Cindy

Steven Busby as Anchorman

Victoria Ippolito as Waitress Emily

Alexandra Vaughan as Hiker Girl

Brian Waters as Dick Santa

Andrew Fultz as Dick Santa 2

Ernie Charles as EMT

Whit Spurgeon as Bus Driver

Christine DiTillio as Martha

Tina Van Berk as Mom

Josh Arnold as Delivery Driver

Kale Shepherd as Santa Con Santa

Aubrey Mozino as Christmas Box Influencer

Molly Flanagan as Mrs. Claus Influencer