Tim Allen as Brad

Kirstie Alley as Caroline

Wayne Knight as Bob Lachman

Larry Miller as Derek Lester

Jay O. Sanders as Samuel Yoder

Michael Lerner as Phil Kleinman

Miguel A. Núñez Jr. as Frank Hall

Megan Cavanagh as Levinia Yoder

John Pyper-Ferguson as Henner Lapp

Carrie Preston as Rebecca Yoder

Ethan Phillips as Jerry

John Caponera as Dave

Katie Moore as Anna Yoder

Bobby Steggert as Samuel Yoder Jr.

Michael Angarano as Sammy Yoder

Rosemary Knower as Grandma Yoder

David Harscheid as Grandpa Yoder

June Claman as Joan Northcutt

Marla Maples as Cynthia

Holly Cross Vagley as Mary

Crystal Bock as Penny

Monica Deeter as Hannah Yoder

Richard Pelzman as Jonathan Yoder

Madeline Mager as Sarah

Terrence Currier as Elder Joseph

Hal Handerson as Elder Thomas

Michael Howell as Bailiff

Johanna Cox as Emma Yoder

Stefan Aleksander as Jacob Yoder

Holly Atkinson as Bank Teller

Emily Chamberlain as Evelyn

Anthony Azizi as Malik

David Maples as IRS Agent

Markus Flanagan as George

Wes Johnson as Tourist

Rick Foucheux as Tom

Drenda Spohnholtz as Waitress

Marla Sucharetza as Stacy

Kirk Alexander as Young Amish Man (uncredited)

John Michaelson as Champagne Waiter (uncredited)

Bryan Spicer as Prisoner (uncredited)

Nick Stellate as Stockbroker (uncredited)

David Scott Taylor as Amish Elder (uncredited)