Tim Curry as Long John Silver

Billy Connolly as Billy Bones

Jennifer Saunders as Mrs. Bluveridge

Kevin Bishop as Jim Hawkins

Dave Goelz as The Great Gonzo / Dr. Bunsen Honeydew / Waldorf / Mudwell the Mudbunny / Zoot (voice)

Steve Whitmire as Kermit the Frog / Rizzo the Rat / Beaker (voice)

Jerry Nelson as Statler / Blind Pew / Mad Monty / Floyd Pepper / Lew Zealand / Tomato / Pirate / Skulls / Trelawney's Butler / Screaming Cat (voice)

Kevin Clash as Bad Polly / Black Dog / Spa'am / Chicken / Miss Piggy (assistant) / Fozzie Bear (assistant) / Sam the Eagle (assistant) / Animal (assistant) / Walleyed Pike / Monkey / Pirate / Real Old Tom (voice)

Bill Barretta as Clueless Morgan / Swedish Chef / Blind Pew (hands) / Pirate / Pig / Skulls (voice)

Frank Oz as Miss Piggy / Fozzie Bear / Sam the Eagle / Animal (voice)

John Henson as Sweetums (voice)

Danny Blackner as Short Stack Stevens

Peter Geeves as Black Eyed Pea

Harry Jones as Easy Pete

David J. Nicholls as Captain Flint

Frederick Warder as Calico Jerry

Nigel Plaskitt as Additional Muppet Performer

Louise Gold as Female Tourist Rat / Rat Tour Guide (voice)

John Eccleston as Additional Muppet Performer

Simon Buckley as Additional Muppet Performer

Katherine Smee as Additional Muppet Performer

Andrew James Spooner as Additional Muppet Performer

Robbie Barnett as Additional Muppet Performer

James Barton as Additional Muppet Performer

Michael Bayliss as Additional Muppet Performer

Charles Broughton as Additional Muppet Performer

David Bulbeck as Additional Muppet Performer

Dave Chapman as Additional Muppet Performer

Marcus Clarke as Additional Muppet Performer

Sue Dacre as Additional Muppet Performer

Taylor David as Additional Muppet Performer

Geoff Felix as Additional Muppet Performer

Mike Gallant as Additional Muppet Performer

Pat Garrett as Additional Muppet Performer

Barnaby Harrison as Additional Muppet Performer

Mark Jefferis as Additional Muppet Performer

William Todd-Jones as Additional Muppet Performer

Robin Kingsland as Additional Muppet Performer

Steven Kynman as Additional Muppet Performer

Christopher Leith as Additional Muppet Performer

Anthony Lymboura as Additional Muppet Performer

Mark Mansfield as Additional Muppet Performer

Joan Morris as Additional Muppet Performer

Rebecca Nagan as Additional Muppet Performer

Margaret O'Flaherty as Additional Muppet Performer

Angie Passmore as Additional Muppet Performer

Peter Passmore as Additional Muppet Performer

Marie Phillips as Additional Muppet Performer

Mike Quinn as Old Woman / Additional Muppet Performer (voice)

Gillie Robic as Additional Muppet Performer

Helena Smee as Additional Muppet Performer

John Thirtle as Additional Muppet Performer

Ian Thom as Additional Muppet Performer

Heather Tobias as Additional Muppet Performer

Jürgen Tombers as Additional Muppet Performer

Ian Tregonning as Additional Muppet Performer

Robert Tygner as Additional Muppet Performer

James Vaughan as Additional Muppet Performer

John Wheatley as Additional Muppet Performer

Victoria Willing as Additional Muppet Performer

Phill Woodfine as Additional Muppet Performer

Sarah Wright as Additional Muppet Performer

Paul Zerdin as Additional Muppet Performer

Jessica Hamilton as Big-Fat-Ugly-Bug-Faced-Baby-Eating O'Brien (uncredited)

Brian Henson as (voice) (uncredited)

Brian Herring as Additional Muppet Performer (uncredited)

Mark Alexander Todd as Boar Warrior (voice) (uncredited)

Peter Robbins as Additional Muppet Performer