Ross Jirgl as Butch Cassidy

Jeffrey Combs as Charles Siringo

Anthony Palermo as Tom Horn

Jilon VanOver as The Sundance Kid (Harry Longabaugh)

Nikki Leigh as Etta Place

Bruce Dern as Mike Cassidy

Dee Wallace as Alice Cassidy

Josh Horton as Isom Dart

Jason Coviello as Ben Kilpatrick

Kyle McKeever as Bob Meeks

Randall Yarbrough as Chas Schumacher

Richard Lippert as Sheriff Beck

Alex Knight as Elzy Lay

Ginger T. Rex as Laura Bullion

Megan Hensley as Maude Davis

David Gibson as Fred

Vic Browder as Eddie