Angela Lansbury as Mrs. Santa Claus

Michael Jeter as Arvo

Terrence Mann as Augustus P. Tavish

Lynsey Bartilson as Nora Kilkenny

Bryan Murray as Officer Doyle

David Norona as Marcello Damoroc

Debra Wiseman as Sadie Lowenstein

Charles Durning as Santa Claus

Rosalind Harris as Mrs. Lowenstein

Grace Keagy as Mrs. Brandenheim

Linda Kerns as Mrs. Shaughnessy

Chachi Pittman as Izzy

Sabrina Bryan as Fritzie

Bret Easterling as Emilio

Mitchah Williams as Henry

Kristi Lynes as Elf #1

Jamie Torcellini as Elf #2

Mick Murray as Michael Kilkenny

Ken Kerman as Stage Doorman

John Wheeler as Man in Santa Suit

Toni Perrotta as Italian Neighbor

Jean Kaufman as Jewish Neighbor

Stacy Sullivan as Miss MacGonnigle